Brandon Daily Sun
19
210
15-NOV-1917
Page 1
ONE TRIBUNAL REFUSES NAMES: OTHER WANTS FULLEST PUBLICITY
ONE TRIBUNAL REFUSES NAMES: OTHER WANTS FULLEST PUBLICITY
ONE
TRIBUNAL
REFUSES
NAMES:
OTHER
WANTS
FULLEST
PUBLICITY
Results
of
Cases
Heard
on
Tues-;
day
Before
Number
Three
Tribunal
The.
members
of
the.
two
Military
Tribunals
hearing
applications
for;
exemptions
have
conflicting
views
as
to
the
expediency
of
publishing
the
names
of
those
who
come
before]
them.
While
Tribunal
No.
Three,
'
consisting
of
Mr.
George
Longley
and
Mr.
A.
C.
McPhall,
with
Captain
EUggl
in
attendance
em
military
represent*
I
tive,
believes
thai
the
public
should
be
made
full)
acquainted
with
the;
work
done,
the
Tribunal
consisting
of;
Mr
I.
A.
Robinson
anil
Mr.
.1.
In
>cs.
with
Major
Whillier
in
attendance,
do
not
think
il
desirable
that
the
lames
should
be
published
They
,al\e
tin'
ground
thai
il
would
lie
un
i'uir
to
those
whose
claims
tor
exemp
tio;i
are
disallowed
Unit
they
should!
Hart
on
their
military
career
with
the
gtlguia,
iii
the
eyes
of
other
soldiers,
of
being
conscripts,
For
this
reason
j
The
Siui
is
only
able
to
give
a
partial!
list
of
those
who
apply
lor
exemp
tion.
II
may
be
stated
that
in
both
cases
the
public
is
admitted
to
th;
sessions,
and
tliougli
tbere
are
case
which
the
authorities
stipulate
maj
he
heard
in
camera,
no
such
case
ha:
as
yet
come
before
either
of
the
loca
tribunals.
Twenty-five
cases
were
disposet
of
by
Messrs.
Robinson
und
lanes
on
Wednesday
as
follows:
Five
claim!
disallowed;
one
man
exempted
to
May
12th,
1918,
due
to
business
obli
gations;
two
exempt
as
unfit;
twe
disallowed
by
default;
ten
allowed
in
the
national
interest;
two
exemp
until
the
men
In
their
medical
cate
gory
are
called;
two
ordered
to
ap
pear
at
a
later
date;
one
referred
to
Appeal
Tribunal.
Tribunal
No.
Three
The
following
cases
were
disposec
of
on
Wednesday
by
Messrs.
Longle>
and
McPhall!
John
Muirhead.
farmer.
Douglas
Man.,
allowed
until
he
ceases
pures
ent
occupation.
Edward
Morris,
U
Fourteentl
street,
brakenian,
claim
disallowed.
Frederick
William
Brandt,
farmer,
Creelford,
Man.,
allowed
until
he
I
ceases
present
occupation.
James
Fraser
Walsh,
movie
oper
ator,
251
Dennis
street,
city.;
allowed
until
services
of
men
in
medical
cate
gory
8
are
required.
Charles
Trethewey,
farmer,
For
rest,
Man.;
allowed
until
he
ceaset>
present
occupation.
Frank
Trent,
fireman,
-25
First
street;
until
he
ceases
present
occu
pation.
Wnlter
White,
student
at
Brandon
College;
dieallowed.
W.
Wesley
Rathwell,
farmer,
May
field,
Man.;
allowed
until
he
ceases
!>ir
I'iit
occupation.
Oswald
TliornCorough,
;ft!O
Filth
street;
until
the
services
of
men
in
his
medical
category
are
required.
Ira
Gus
Quigley,
barber,
II2S
Fourth
street,
Brandon;
allowed
for
domes
tic
reasons.
Fraser
'McKinnon,
student,
;!4
Eighth
street;
unfit.
Alexander
Synl
Miller,
03
Enghth
■treat,
ammunitoa
worker;
until
the
services
of
men
in
medical
category
C
are
required.
John
Donald
McDonald,
movie
op
erator,
456
Sixth
street;
unfit.
Gordon
F.
Holmes,
farmer,
Bran
don;
allowed
until
he
ceuses
present
occupation.
Owen
Jones,
book-keeper,
508
Rus
sell
street,
disallowed.
Arthur
Webb,
229
Twelfth
street;
unfit.
Ralph
Mashinter.
141
borne
avenue.
'arming;
disallowed.
Stanley
Leeson,
25
sixth
street;
Hsallowed.
Alexander
Mann,
gardener,
Brandon
asylum;
allowed
for
domestic
rea
sons.
Herbert
Ilam?,den,
engineer,
122
Russell
street;
ullowed
until
he
ceaaes
present,
occupation.
Frederick
A.
Wilson,
book-keeper,
110
Sixth
street;
until
men
in
medi
al
category
C
are
called
up.
J.
W.
Broftvnridge,
farming;
until
he
ceases
present
occupation.
James
Wi
>bster,
farm
laborer,
R.
R.
\'o.
:j,
Uran'don;
disallowed
by
default.
Jas.
G.
Jones,
teamster,
120
First
street;
di?
lallowod
by
default.